Icey Tek vs Yeti: One Holds Ice The Longest

ICEY-TEK 40 Quart High Performance Cooler

ICEY-TEK Cooler

vs

YETI Tundra 45 Cooler, White

YETI Cooler

When you are going out on a hot day and want to keep your beverages and sandwiches cool, bringing along a cooler full of ice is a must. There are many coolers on the market to choose from, some purporting to be high end and thus being more expensive.

But without having any input as to how long the ice lasts in a cooler, how can a customer really tell whether the claims of the company are true?

We have done some research into what customers are saying about the differences between the Icey Tek and the Yeti.

Overall, there are three major differences between them as far as we can tell. We’re going to go over each of these differences in the sections below.

Icey Tek vs Yeti

Preview
ICEY-TEK Cooler
ICEY-TEK Classic 40 Quart Rotomolded Cooler - Tailgating, Fishing, Hunting, Camping, Catering, Medical Transport and The Beach
YETI Cooler
YETI Tundra 45 Cooler, White
Title
ICEY-TEK Classic 40 Quart Rotomolded Cooler - Tailgating, Fishing, Hunting, Camping, Catering, Medical Transport and The Beach
YETI Tundra 45 Cooler, White
Price
Price not available
$299.98
Storage Capacity
40 quart
45 quarts
Dimensions
22.00" x 17.50" x 17.00"
25.75" x 16.2 x 15.38"
Under lid carry handles
Yes
Yes
Rotomolded
Yes
Yes
Weight
17 lbs
23 lbs
Technology
Marine-Grade Neoprene Lid Gasket | Dual-Skin Temperature Retention TEKnology™
FATWALL™ Design | PermaFrost™ Insulation
More Information
ICEY-TEK Cooler
Preview
ICEY-TEK Classic 40 Quart Rotomolded Cooler - Tailgating, Fishing, Hunting, Camping, Catering, Medical Transport and The Beach
Title
ICEY-TEK Classic 40 Quart Rotomolded Cooler - Tailgating, Fishing, Hunting, Camping, Catering, Medical Transport and The Beach
Price
Price not available
Storage Capacity
40 quart
Dimensions
22.00" x 17.50" x 17.00"
Under lid carry handles
Yes
Rotomolded
Yes
Weight
17 lbs
Technology
Marine-Grade Neoprene Lid Gasket | Dual-Skin Temperature Retention TEKnology™
More Information
YETI Cooler
Preview
YETI Tundra 45 Cooler, White
Title
YETI Tundra 45 Cooler, White
Price
$299.98
Storage Capacity
45 quarts
Dimensions
25.75" x 16.2 x 15.38"
Under lid carry handles
Yes
Rotomolded
Yes
Weight
23 lbs
Technology
FATWALL™ Design | PermaFrost™ Insulation
More Information

Which Is The Priciest?

If you know a bit about coolers already, you might’ve guessed that the Yeti is the costliest of the two. However, while some people used to say that the Yeti is twice as pricey, it seems like it has come down in price. On Amazon, similarly sized Icey Tek coolers are comparable in price to the Yeti.

Many people consider price an important factor when wanting to purchase one or the other. They feel that the Yeti is the higher-end model because it is so popular and has such a good reputation. Let’s compare the other features below.

Considering The Weight

Weight is a major consideration when it comes to coolers, as they naturally tend to be heavy. The Yeti is the heaviest of the two when comparing model that have roughly the same volume capacity. For some people, this does not make a difference. For example, if you’re just going to be going to a camping site and leaving the cooler there for days, the weight of the Yeti is not such a big hassle.

But if you need to take your cooler onto a boat, some customers feel that the Yeti would be too heavy for that. In response, they sometimes choose the Icey Tek for the convenience of being able to take it on and off the boat.

If you’re going to be doing a lot of moving around, perhaps the Icey Tek would have an advantage over the Yeti.

How Long They Hold Ice

While a small number of customers who owned both of these coolers feel like they both do a good job at holding ice, the majority of reviews state that they have trouble keeping ice in the Icey Tek on a hot summer day. Some say that it can only keep ice for about one or two days. This would not be enough for an extended stay on a camping trip.

Conversely, the Yeti can hold ice for 4-5 days according to customer reviews.

Icey Tek vs Yeti: Price Comparison

Useful Tips

In order to make your ice last longer in either one of these coolers, make sure that you don’t put it into the cooler when it is hot. First, cool down your cooler with some ice. Then put in some more ice and shut the lid.

Another useful tip is to use dry ice. This will aid in ice retention. However, you must use safety precautions. For example, don’t leave much air inside of the cooler after having put in the ice, as the ice can expand and even explode!

Icey Tek vs Yeti: The Verdict

Which cooler customers end up purchasing is a matter of either utility or emotional preference. Some people like the Yeti due to its higher class status. When people see the logo of the Yeti on the side of the box, it makes them feel as though others will take notice and they will win brownie points.

But for most people, they just want the utility of a good cooler. If weight is an issue, the Yeti is perhaps not the best choice. But if you’re going to be going on a long trip that will last several days, the Yeti will hold ice for the duration of your trip.

If you’re only going to be about for a day or less, the Icey Tek will do the trick.

OffTheGridGearHub.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Some links may be affiliate links. We may get paid if you buy something or take an action after clicking one of these

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *